If you’ve hired a personal injury lawyer but aren’t satisfied with how your case is being handled, you may be wondering: Can I change attorneys in the middle of my case? The answer is yes—and in many situations, it’s not only allowed, but the best move for your claim.
Here’s what you need to know about switching lawyers mid-case in New York.
Yes, You Have the Right to Switch Attorneys
Under New York law, you are entitled to change lawyers at any time, for any reason—even if your case is already in progress. Your case belongs to you, and your legal representation should reflect your best interests.
Common Reasons People Change Lawyers
- Lack of communication (unanswered calls or emails)
- You feel ignored or rushed
- Disagreements about case strategy or settlement decisions
- You’ve lost confidence in their ability
- Your lawyer is pressuring you to settle too quickly
- The firm lacks experience with your type of injury or case
If you feel uneasy or frustrated, it’s worth discussing your concerns—or getting a second opinion.
How to Switch Lawyers (It’s Easier Than You Think)
- Consult a new attorney
Find someone who’s experienced, responsive, and willing to take over the case. - Sign a retainer agreement with the new lawyer
Once you hire them, they’ll handle the transition. - Your new lawyer will notify your current lawyer
They’ll request your case file and manage the transfer.
You don’t have to personally break the news or negotiate anything—it’s all handled behind the scenes.
Will It Cost Me More to Switch?
Not usually. In most cases, your new and former attorneys split the contingency fee at the end of the case. You won’t pay more out-of-pocket for switching.
Your new lawyer will also:
- Review any fee arrangements
- Handle fee disputes (if any) with the previous lawyer
Timing Matters
You can switch attorneys at almost any stage, but the earlier, the better. This allows your new lawyer time to:
- Review the case
- Fix any issues or oversights
- Build a stronger legal strategy
That said, even if your case is close to settlement or trial, switching may still be worth it if it leads to better results.
You Deserve Representation You Trust
Your injury claim is too important to settle for anything less than excellent legal representation. If something doesn’t feel right, trust your instincts—you have the power to switch.
Thinking about changing lawyers? We offer second opinions—no pressure, no obligation.
Contact the Personal Injury Law Firm of Figeroux & Associates
Schedule a free consultation today!
Call 855-768-8845
Visit www.askthelawyer.us
