Blog

The Trump administration’s “tough on crime” rhetoric revived a punitive approach to law enforcement that disproportionately impacted communities of color. Although many of these policies originated decades earlier, Trump’s open endorsement of aggressive policing and mass incarceration compounded systemic injustices. The result: increased arrests, harsher prosecutions, and heightened fear among Black and brown communities—even for low-level or non-violent offenses.

In New York State (NYS), these national trends intersected with local challenges, including NYPD racial profiling, broken windows policing, and uneven access to quality defense. Against this backdrop, criminal defense attorneys play a critical role not only in safeguarding individual liberty, but in resisting institutional abuse and rebuilding public trust in the justice system.

This article explores strategic approaches NYS attorneys can use to defend clients, particularly those from marginalized backgrounds, who continue to face the legacy of racially biased policing and prosecutorial overreach.

1. Challenging Unlawful Stops and Searches

A cornerstone of Trump’s “law and order” agenda was empowering police discretion, which frequently translated to unconstitutional stops and searches—especially in minority communities.

Attorney Strategies:

• File suppression motions under the Fourth Amendment to challenge evidence obtained through unlawful searches.
• Cross-examine officers aggressively on inconsistencies in their stop-and-frisk justifications.
• Use body camera footage and police radio transmissions to contradict officer narratives.
• Invoke People v. De Bour to scrutinize the legal justification at each stage of the police encounter in NYS.

2. Combating Racial Profiling and Disparate Enforcement

Communities of color were over-policed under both federal and local mandates. Disparities in arrests for offenses like marijuana possession persisted even after statewide reforms.

Attorney Strategies:

• Request discovery on racial demographics of arrests and compare with client profiles to build racial profiling claims.
• File selective enforcement motions under the Equal Protection Clause, using data and witness testimony.
• Push for diversion alternatives for low-level offenses, particularly when arrest patterns show racial bias.
• Use expert testimony to link client experience to broader patterns of discriminatory policing.

3. Defending Against Coerced Plea Deals

With Trump-era rhetoric emphasizing conviction rates and “zero tolerance,” prosecutors often pushed for plea bargains under coercive conditions—especially for poor or unrepresented defendants.

Attorney Strategies:

• Ensure clients fully understand the consequences of plea deals, including immigration, housing, and employment impacts.
• File motions to withdraw pleas if coercion, misinformation, or ineffective counsel can be proven.
• Document plea negotiations thoroughly to protect against future challenges or misrepresentations by the prosecution.
• Negotiate from a position of strength, emphasizing weaknesses in the prosecution’s case or constitutional violations.

4. Advocating for Bail Reform and Pretrial Release

Trump and his allies criticized bail reform efforts, claiming they led to rising crime. In NYS, reforms were rolled back under public pressure, affecting pretrial justice for low-income and minority defendants.

Attorney Strategies:

• Argue for least restrictive conditions of release under NYS Criminal Procedure Law § 510.10.
• Highlight stable community ties, employment, and family responsibilities to support bail applications.
• Challenge pretrial detention as a due process violation if delays or excessive conditions are imposed.
• Appeal excessive bail through writs of habeas corpus when appropriate.

5. Confronting Prosecutorial Misconduct and Overcharging

Prosecutors, emboldened by political pressures, often overcharged defendants to secure plea deals or boost conviction stats—a practice disproportionately harming communities of color.

Attorney Strategies:

• Demand full discovery under NY’s expanded discovery laws (CPL Article 245).
• Move to dismiss charges that are unsupported by evidence or constitute overcharging.
• File Brady and Giglio motions to force the prosecution to reveal exculpatory or impeaching material.
• Expose bias in charging decisions, especially where similarly situated white defendants received leniency.

6. Defending Youth of Color in the Juvenile and Adult Systems

Despite NYS’s Raise the Age legislation, many young people of color continue to face adult prosecution for minor infractions.

Attorney Strategies:

• Move to transfer youth back to Family Court, emphasizing rehabilitative needs and developmental science.
• Build mitigation narratives that contextualize behavior within environmental and social challenges.
• Advocate for diversion and youth services, avoiding criminal records that can derail a young person’s future.
• Challenge school-based arrests as part of dismantling the school-to-prison pipeline.

7. Sentencing Advocacy and Alternatives to Incarceration

Mandatory minimums and punitive sentencing policies saw renewed support under Trump. Even in NYS, sentencing disparities remain a reality for marginalized defendants.

Attorney Strategies:

• Prepare detailed pre-sentencing reports, including character letters, psychological evaluations, and community support.
• Argue for alternative sentencing such as drug treatment, mental health court, or community service.
• Cite New York-specific laws like the Judicial Diversion Program for felony drug cases.
• Challenge sentence enhancements tied to prior convictions, particularly those stemming from racially biased enforcement.

8. Addressing Immigration Consequences of Criminal Charges

Under Trump, even minor criminal charges could trigger immigration enforcement. Non-citizen defendants faced deportation, detention, and denial of relief.

Attorney Strategies:

• Advise clients pre-plea on the immigration consequences of convictions, in compliance with Padilla v. Kentucky.
• Collaborate with immigration attorneys to identify charges that avoid triggering removability.
• Negotiate pleas to non-deportable offenses, such as disorderly conduct instead of assault or drug possession.
• File post-conviction relief motions (CPL § 440.10) to vacate convictions with adverse immigration effects.

9. Litigation for Wrongful Arrests and Malicious Prosecution

Aggressive and sometimes unlawful arrests increased during Trump’s presidency. NYS residents—particularly Black and Latino New Yorkers—continue to face wrongful prosecutions based on weak or false evidence.

Attorney Strategies:

• File civil suits under Section 1983 or state law for false arrest, malicious prosecution, and abuse of process.
• Subpoena arrest records and body camera footage to expose inconsistencies or rights violations.
• Pursue disciplinary complaints against officers engaged in repeated misconduct.
• Use NYS Civil Rights Law § 50-a repeal to access police disciplinary records in litigation.

10. Advocacy for Systemic Reform and Legislative Change

Legal defense alone cannot dismantle the policies and practices that led to mass incarceration. Attorneys must engage in broader reform efforts.

Attorney Strategies:

• Partner with reform groups like The Legal Aid Society, Bronx Defenders, and NYCLU on impact litigation.
• Support Clean Slate legislation to seal or expunge old convictions.
• Push for sentencing reform, discovery law enforcement, and public defender funding.
• Educate communities on legal rights through “know your rights” trainings and court navigation programs.

Conclusion

The Trump administration’s criminal justice posture intensified longstanding disparities and legitimized over-policing of vulnerable communities. For New York State attorneys, this has meant more than just handling higher case volumes—it has required creative, aggressive, and deeply informed legal strategy to resist the erosion of justice.

Whether challenging unconstitutional stops, fighting coercive plea deals, or advocating for systemic change, criminal defense attorneys are the vanguard of fairness in a legal system still grappling with racial bias. The post-Trump era offers a chance to rebuild and reimagine justice—but only if legal advocates continue to challenge power, defend rights, and hold the system accountable.