Blog

The relationship between landlords and tenants is fundamental to housing and commerce in New York. However, this relationship is often fraught with conflict, leading to a significant volume of disputes across both residential and commercial sectors. From bustling urban centers like New York City to suburban towns and rural areas, issues ranging from rent payment to property conditions fuel disagreements that frequently necessitate legal intervention. Figeroux & Associates, conveniently located at 26 Court Street, Suite 701, Brooklyn, NY 11242, possesses deep expertise in navigating the complexities of New York State (NYS) and New York City (NYC) landlord-tenant law. For assistance, contact the firm at 855-768-8845 or visit www.askthelawyer.us. This analysis explores common landlord-tenant disputes and the intricate legal framework governing them, particularly within the unique context of NYC.   

The Lease: Foundation of the Relationship

At its core, the landlord-tenant relationship is contractual, typically defined by a written lease agreement (though oral leases under one year are permissible, written agreements are strongly advised). This lease outlines the rights and obligations of both parties, covering rent amount and due dates, lease duration, use restrictions, repair responsibilities, and rules regarding occupancy, alterations, and subletting. Under New York’s Statute of Frauds (General Obligations Law § 5-701), leases for a term longer than one year must be in writing to be enforceable. Clarity in lease drafting is essential to prevent disputes arising from ambiguous terms.   

Common Areas of Landlord-Tenant Conflict

Disputes can arise over numerous issues, governed by NYS Real Property Law (RPL), Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL), General Obligations Law (GOL), and, significantly in NYC, the Administrative Code and Rent Regulations.

1. Non-Payment Proceedings (RPAPL Article 7): This is arguably the most common dispute. When a tenant fails to pay rent, the landlord can initiate a summary proceeding in court (typically NYC Housing Court) to recover the unpaid rent and/or evict the tenant. The process requires strict adherence to procedural steps:   
   • Rent Demand: A formal, written 14-day notice demanding the overdue rent or possession of the premises.   
   • Notice of Petition and Petition: If rent isn’t paid after the demand period, the landlord files these documents with the court, officially starting the eviction case. The petition must state the facts supporting the claim (RPAPL § 741).   
   • Service: The tenant must be properly served with the court papers.
   • Court Appearance: Both parties appear in court. Tenants may raise defenses, such as breach of the warranty of habitability or, for regulated units, rent overcharge.   
2. Holdover Proceedings (RPAPL Article 7): These proceedings seek eviction for reasons other than non-payment. Common grounds include:   
   • Lease Expiration: The tenant remains after the lease term ends without a valid renewal.
   • Lease Violations: Breaching a substantial lease term, such as having unauthorized occupants or pets, illegal subletting, causing a nuisance, or using the property for illegal purposes.   
   • Notice Requirements: Holdover cases require specific predicate notices before court filing. A Notice to Cure might be required first, giving the tenant time to fix the violation. A Notice of Termination follows, formally ending the tenancy. The length of these notices varies depending on the lease, tenancy duration, and regulatory status (RPL § 226-c, § 232-a, § 232-b). Failure to serve proper notices is grounds for dismissal.
3. Warranty of Habitability (RPL § 235-b): Implied in every residential lease is the landlord’s promise that the premises are fit for human habitation and free from conditions dangerous to life, health, or safety. This includes providing essential services like heat (specific temperature minimums required by law) and hot water, maintaining structural integrity, and addressing pest infestations or hazardous conditions (e.g., lead paint).   
   • Tenant Remedies: If breached, tenants can: 
     • Sue for a rent abatement (reduction) in court.
     • Withhold rent (though this will likely trigger a non-payment case where the breach is raised as a defense/counterclaim).
     • For rent-regulated tenants, file a service reduction complaint with the NYS Division of Housing and Community Renewal (DHCR).
     • In NYC, initiate an HP Action in Housing Court to compel repairs (see below).
     • In limited circumstances, make repairs and deduct the reasonable cost from rent after proper notice.
4. Security Deposits (GOL § 7-108): Strict rules govern security deposits in NYS:
   • Limit: Typically capped at one month’s rent.
   • Holding: Must be kept in a separate, interest-bearing account (if applicable) in a NY bank; landlord must notify tenant of bank name/address.   
   • Return: Landlord must return the deposit within 14 days of the tenant vacating, minus any itemized deductions for damages beyond normal wear and tear or unpaid rent. Landlords must offer a pre-move-out inspection.   
   • Penalties: Failure to follow these rules, especially the 14-day itemized return, can result in the landlord forfeiting the right to retain any portion and potentially being liable for damages up to twice the deposit amount if the violation was willful.   
5. Illegal Subletting/Assignment (RPL § 226-b): Tenants in buildings with four or more units generally have a right to request permission to sublet. Landlords cannot unreasonably withhold consent. The law outlines a specific procedure for the tenant’s request and the landlord’s response. Unreasonable refusal allows the tenant to proceed with the sublet. Unauthorized subletting or assignment constitutes a substantial breach of the lease, potentially leading to a holdover eviction.   
6. Nuisance: Actions by a tenant that substantially interfere with the health, safety, comfort, or repose of other tenants or the landlord (e.g., excessive noise, harassment, unsanitary conditions) can be grounds for a holdover eviction.   
7. Landlord Harassment (RPL § 235-d; NYC Admin Code § 27-2004(a)(48), § 27-2005): Defined broadly as any act or omission by the landlord intended to cause a tenant to vacate or surrender rights. This includes threatening force, interrupting essential services, bringing repeated baseless court actions, or illegal lockouts. NYC law provides specific civil penalties. Tenants can seek injunctions and damages in court or file complaints with DHCR (if rent-regulated).   

The NYC Context: A Regulatory Web

Landlord-tenant law in NYC is significantly shaped by local regulations and dedicated institutions:

• Rent Regulation (Rent Stabilization & Rent Control): Administered by DHCR, these laws cover roughly half of NYC’s rental stock. They limit rent increases, mandate lease renewals, regulate services, and provide strong eviction protections. Landlords must register units and rents annually. Disputes over rent amounts, required services, or lease renewals for these units are often handled initially by DHCR.   
• NYC Housing Court: A part of the Civil Court, it handles a massive volume of non-payment and holdover cases, illegal lockout proceedings, and HP Actions. Proceedings are intended to be faster (“summary”), but the sheer volume and complexity can still lead to delays. Representation by knowledgeable counsel is highly advantageous.
• HP Actions (Housing Part Actions): A vital tool for NYC tenants. Tenants (or HPD itself) can file an HP Action to compel landlords to make repairs and correct violations of the Housing Maintenance Code. The court can issue orders to correct, impose fines, and oversee repairs. HPD often inspects and may participate in the case. This is often a more proactive and safer approach than rent withholding.   
• “Good Cause Eviction” Law (RPL Art. 6-A): Enacted statewide effective April 20, 2024, and applying within NYC, this law extends significant protections to tenants in previously unregulated market-rate apartments (with specific exemptions). Landlords now need a “good cause” (enumerated in the statute, similar to grounds for regulated tenants) to evict or not renew a lease. It also allows tenants facing non-payment eviction to challenge “unreasonable” rent increases (presumed unreasonable if above 5% + CPI, capped at 10%; currently 8.82% in NYC). The law imposes strict new notice requirements on landlords regarding its applicability in leases, rent demands, and court filings. Exemptions exist for small landlords (owning 10 or fewer units statewide), owner-occupied buildings with 10 or fewer units, and certain other situations.   
• Other NYC Laws: Includes specific requirements for window guards, lead paint abatement, heat/hot water provision, and recent legislation like the “Fair Chance for Housing Act” (limiting criminal background checks, effective Jan 2025) and the “FARE Act” (barring landlords from charging tenants for the landlord’s broker fee, effective mid-2025 pending legal challenges).   

The Indispensable Role of Legal Counsel

The intricate tapestry of state statutes, local ordinances, rent regulations, and court procedures makes navigating landlord-tenant disputes in New York, especially NYC, exceptionally challenging. Whether you are a landlord seeking to enforce lease terms or recover possession, or a tenant facing eviction, habitability issues, or harassment, understanding your rights and obligations is crucial. Procedural missteps can lead to case dismissal or loss of rights. Figeroux & Associates provides invaluable assistance by ensuring compliance, drafting clear agreements, negotiating settlements, and providing zealous advocacy in DHCR proceedings and Housing Court litigation.

Conclusion

Landlord-tenant disputes are a pervasive feature of the New York real estate landscape. From basic non-payment cases to complex holdovers involving rent-stabilized tenants or warranty of habitability claims under HP Actions, the legal framework is multifaceted and constantly evolving, as evidenced by the recent Good Cause Eviction law. The dense regulations and specialized court system in NYC add further layers of complexity. Successfully navigating these challenges requires diligence, knowledge, and often skilled legal representation. Figeroux & Associates (855-768-8845 | www.askthelawyer.us) offers the expertise necessary to protect the rights and interests of both landlords and tenants in these intricate matters.